Tesla’s share price is once again dominating financial headlines, with the electric vehicle giant’s stock taking a beating in early July 2025. Closing at $293.94 on July 7, down 6.79% in pre-market trading, Tesla has shed over 50% of its value since its peak of $479.86 in December 2024. So, what’s driving this volatility, and is Tesla still a buy? Let’s unpack the story.
A Turbulent Year for Tesla’s Stock
Tesla’s 2025 has been anything but smooth. The stock, now trading at $293.94, is down nearly 22% year-to-date, a stark contrast to its meteoric 161.50% rise from its 52-week low of $182.00. Yet, it remains 60.17% below its all-time high of $488.54. With a market cap still towering at $1.02 trillion, Tesla is a heavyweight, but its recent 15% single-day plunge in March 2025—the worst in five years—has rattled even the most loyal shareholders.
The numbers tell a tale of struggle. Tesla’s price-to-earnings ratio sits at a sky-high 161.78, signaling that investors are still betting big on future growth despite recent setbacks. But with a 13.5% drop in vehicle deliveries in Q2 2025 and earnings per share of $0.27 missing estimates of $0.41, the market’s patience is wearing thin.
Why the Slide?
Several forces are conspiring to drag Tesla’s stock lower:
- Slumping Sales and Fierce Competition: Tesla’s global deliveries are faltering, with a 13.5% year-over-year decline in Q2 following a similar drop in Q1. Meanwhile, rivals like China’s BYD are surging ahead, posting a 90.4% sales increase in the same period. In Europe, Tesla’s sales tanked, with Germany reporting a 76% plunge in February 2025, even as the broader EV market grew by 31%.
- Elon Musk’s Political Firestorm: Tesla’s CEO, Elon Musk, has stirred controversy with his deep involvement in U.S. politics, including a leadership role in the Trump administration’s Department of Government Efficiency and the launch of a new “America Party.” This has sparked backlash, with reports of vandalism at Tesla facilities and a dip in consumer sentiment in key markets.
- Policy Shifts and Economic Headwinds: The U.S. government’s decision to end $7,500 EV tax credits, signed into law on July 4, 2025, has hit demand hard. New tariffs proposed by the Trump administration are also raising concerns about supply chain costs. Add to that volatile raw material prices and shrinking subsidies in Europe and China, and Tesla’s margins are under pressure.
- Disappointing Earnings: Tesla’s Q1 2025 financials were grim, with revenue down 9% to $19.3 billion and profits plummeting 71% to $409 million. The latest quarter didn’t fare much better, with revenue of $19.34 billion falling short of Wall Street’s $21.27 billion forecast. Investors are questioning whether Tesla can deliver on its growth promises.
- Robotaxi Dreams vs. Reality: Tesla’s recent robotaxi launch in Austin has sparked some hope, with analysts at Benchmark raising their price target to $475, citing a “safe and scalable” rollout. But skepticism persists. Tesla’s camera-only autonomous driving system faces stiff competition from lidar-equipped rivals like Waymo.
Wall Street’s Take: Optimism or Caution?
Analysts are split on Tesla’s future. TipRanks reports an average 12-month price target of $291.31, just below the current price, with a “Hold” consensus from 35 analysts (14 buy, 12 hold, 9 sell). Optimists point to Tesla’s robotaxi potential and upcoming affordable models, while bears warn of brand damage and delivery woes. HSBC called Tesla’s strong June sales an “aberration,” and Baird’s Ben Kallo flagged risks from Musk’s political distractions. At the extremes, price targets range from a bullish $500 to a grim $19.05.
Technically, Tesla’s stock is testing key support around $300. A break below could see it slide to $265 or even $190, while a move above $360 might signal a recovery. The relative strength index is nearing oversold levels, hinting at a possible rebound, but sentiment remains fragile.
The Road Ahead
Tesla’s path forward depends on a few critical factors:
- Robotaxi Rollout: A successful expansion of the robotaxi service could restore investor confidence, but regulatory and technical challenges loom large.
- New Models: Affordable vehicles and a refreshed Model Y could revive sales, especially in markets like India, where Tesla is eyeing a manufacturing push.
- China and Beyond: Regaining ground in China against BYD and capitalizing on India’s EV boom will be crucial.
- Musk’s Focus: Investors want Musk to prioritize Tesla over his political and side ventures at SpaceX and X.
Should You Bet on Tesla?
For now, Tesla is a high-stakes gamble. Its leadership in EVs and energy storage, coupled with its autonomous driving ambitions, makes it a compelling long-term play. But near-term risks—slumping sales, competitive pressures, and Musk’s controversies—demand caution.
With Tesla’s stock teetering at a critical level, investors must weigh the potential for a rebound against the very real challenges ahead. For those on the fence, the next few quarters will be telling. Stay tuned—this story is far from over.
Last Updated on Tuesday, July 8, 2025 6:00 pm by Rishi Akkaraju
About The Author
